When you really stop to think about it, memory cards
are a pretty delicate storage format for something as
important as your digital photos.
So many things can happen to memory cards: They can get
lost, stolen, corrupted or, in the case of those little
tiny xD-Picture cards, blown into the next ZIP code when
you sneeze.
The point, of course, is that memory cards are designed
for temporary storage inside the camera. Once the card is
full, your photos desperately want to be transferred to
some larger, safer, more permanent home.
Of course, for most people, that home is a computer.
But hauling a laptop around on your sightseeing trips
isn't always practical. Besides, it's like wearing a
T-shirt that says, "I'm a Tourist--Rob Me."
You could buy a whole bunch of memory cards, but that
gets expensive. You could also buy a portable CD recorder
(about $275) that burns photos right from the card, but
that's bulky and slow.
But hey, this is the era of tiny hard drives. Why can't
someone invent a handheld gadget that slurps photos off a
memory card and onto a hard drive, so you can wipe the
card clean and get back to shooting?
Fortunately, several someones have invented just that:
Gadgets variously called photo vaults, photo wallets,
digital photo viewers and mobile media hard drives. Or, if
you have an iPod music player, you can turn it into a
photo vault, too, using adapters sold by Belkin and Apple
Computer, which has just introduced something called the
iPod Photo Connector.
The dedicated photo vaults (from Epson, Archos, Nikon,
SmartDisk, Jobo and others) have several advantages over
the iPod adapters. First, they have much bigger screens,
making it easy to show your pictures to your friends and
delete the losers. (The photos, that is, not the friends.)
Second, they can also play music and sometimes movies,
although in a limited number of file formats; for example,
most can't play copy-protected songs you buy off the
Internet. (When connected to a Mac or PC through a USB
cable, these devices act like external hard drives--that's
how you load music and movies--and memory-card readers.)
Third, you can hook up any of these players to a
television, the better to elicit oohs and aahs from your
entourage.
Finally, these devices have their own battery packs and
memory-card slots. When you transfer the pictures, in
other words, you're not draining your camera's battery (as
you would when connecting it to a laptop). That's
important because when you're out and about,
camera-battery juice is a precious resource.
Choice of bells, whistles
The photo vaults in this roundup--the Epson P-2000, Jobo
GigaVu Pro, Archos AV420 and SmartDisk FlashTrax--present
a wide range of choice in size, shape, bells and whistles.
(Nikon, whose compact Coolwalker MSV-01 is intended for
use with Nikon cameras, declined to provide a unit for
evaluation. This roundup also omits screenless models,
which deprive you of half the fun.)
Most have a slot only for Compact Flash cards. If your
camera uses a smaller type, you're expected to provide
your own card adapter. Only the Epson P-2000 also offers a
slot for SD cards.
Nor is that the only virtue of the sleek black Epson
($500 online). The size, brightness and clarity of its
3.8-inch screen blows its competition off the equipment
rack. Thanks to its supercrisp 640 pixels by 480 pixels
(four times the resolution of its rivals), photos look
like glossy drugstore prints. Photo transfer is fast: just
under two minutes for a 256MB memory card filled with 103
pictures.
This is also the only photo vault that's serious about
slide shows: You can choose background music, and you can
opt for gentle animated panning and cross-dissolving
effects that lend a sweet, soft-focus, Hallmark Hall of
Fame feeling.
But at 5.8 inches by 3.3 inches by 1.2 inches, the
Epson is not what you'd call petite. If you'd prefer
something more compact, investigate the genuinely
pocketable Archos AV420 (4.9 inches by 3.1 inche by 0.8
inches).
Now, the Archos ($450) was never intended to be a photo
wallet; it began life as a pocket multimedia machine,
capable of, for example, recording television shows (even
unattended) so you can watch them on the road. But because
it's so slim, so capacious (up to 100GB) and fast (1
minute 40 seconds to transfer
that 256MB card), photographers have begun adopting it
for photo-offloading use.
It's nowhere near as good as the Epson at that task,
though. The 3.5-inch screen is only 320 pixels by 240
pixels; there's no dedicated Transfer Photos command or
button; it can't display RAW files of any type; and you
don't get any kind of progress indicator or thumbnails of
incoming photos while you're importing. But did I mention
that it's small?
Small is not the word for the bulbous Jobo GigaVu Pro (5.7
inches by 4.2 inches by 1.5 inches). This device seems
aimed at more serious photographers, both in its price
($500 for the 40GB model), its handling of advanced photo
formats like RAW and TIFF, its speed (3:09 for the 256MB
test) and, alas, its confusing operating system. (Why, for
example, don't the unavailable options grow dim or
disappear, as on any self-respecting operating system?)
The protective lid, which you can snap underneath when
you're using the thing, is a nice touch, but most people
would be happier with the Epson.
SmartDisk's FlashTrax protects its own screen, too: You
flip it up to use it, as though it's the Terminator's
makeup compact. This device is remarkably devoted to its
task: Without knowing a thing about the Windows-esque
filing system, you insert your memory card, press the Copy
button, and the deed is done. Other grace notes include a
swappable battery, and the ability to play back your
digital camera's movies.
The FlashTrax is also notable for its price: $280 for
the 20GB model, or $350 for 40GB (both prices reflect a
$50 rebate good through April 30). Note, however, that
much of the economy comes from the inclusion of the
homeliest, most washed-out screen of the lot.
Now, if you have an iPod music player, you're already
carrying around a 10GB or 60GB hard drive, and in a unit
that's much smaller than any standalone photo vault.
Battery draining
Belkin offers two camera-to-iPod transfer adapters. The
Digital Camera Link (about $56 online) is a white plastic
box that connects your camera (through its USB cable)
directly to the iPod. The transfer is slow (6:45 for the
256MB card), the device is bulky (the size of the iPod
itself), it drains your camera's battery, and it eats up
its own AA batteries like there's no tomorrow. And on
black-and-white iPods, you don't actually see the photos;
each transfer is identified on the iPod screen only by
name, date, file sizes and number of pictures.
The Belkin Media Reader ($100) is another, even bigger
white plastic box (3.4 inches by 4 inches by 0.8 inches),
this time loaded with four AAA batteries. The transfer is
even slower - over 9 minutes for that 256MB card test. But
this time, you don't drain your camera's battery because
you put the memory card directly into the Belkin.
In both cases, your Mac or PC imports the photos from
the iPod exactly as you would from a digital camera.
Life is much sweeter if you have Apple's iPod Photo
($350 for the 30GB model), which has a color screen. In
that case, you can use Apple's new iPod Photo Connector
($30), a tiny, white plastic doohickey that snaps directly
onto the iPod. When you connect your camera's USB cable to
it, the iPod cheerfully offers to import the photos.
During the importing process, you see each photo as it
comes in, along with helpful progress indicators and a
choice of "Stop and Save" and "Cancel"
buttons.
The charms of this solution, of course, include its
extreme tininess, very low cost and compatibility with
those big RAW files and digital movies (which the iPod can
import but not display).
The drawbacks are considerable, though. The transfer is
very slow (10.5 minutes for that 256MB card), and the
iPod's battery takes quite a hit. Note, too, that although
you can view the imported photos on the screen, the iPod
Photo can't display them on a television--one of the
device's best features--until you've returned home and
synchronized them with your Mac or PC, which puts them
back on the iPod in the proper format.
Thanks to an annoying little thing called physics, you
can't have fast, cheap, small body, big hard drive and big
screen all in one gadget.
If you prefer small and capacious, though, an iPod
Photo with the little adapter represents the tiniest
photo-wallet system you can buy--and, oh yeah, you get a
really great music player at no extra charge. For savings
and ruggedness, choose the SmartDisk FlashTrax. If you
prefer a big screen and speed, you'll be thrilled by the
spectacular display on the Epson P-2000. Any way you go,
the next time you're traveling, you'll sleep better
knowing that your photos are safely snuggled into a little
digital hotel room of their very own.